Comparison between MiG-3 and other fighters
last modified on June 20, 2003
back to MiG-3 main

Another regiment able to fly well the MiG-3 was the 55 IAP on the Southern Front; it was the unit of the future Hero of the Soviet Union Alexander Pokryshkin, that obtained his  first 12 victories on a MiG-3; of these, 5 were on Bf-109E of Jagdgeschwader 77.
He was one of the first pilots to understand that the good manoeuvrability of the MiG-3 on the vertical plan should be exploited flying high, then diving on the enemy gaining speed, use it to choose a good firing position, fire and then pitch to regain altitude and to subtract to the reaction of the enemy.

A comparison between MiG-3 and Me-109

MiG-3s were slightly more manoeuvrable than Bf-109E on the vertical plane, even at low altitudes that were disadvantaging for the Soviet fighter. This technique was used by German themselves while combatting against Polish PZL-11 two years before: the slow and highly manoeuvrable Polish fighters took advantage to combat turning, until the Me-109s started to jump on them from above.
The combat on the horizontal plan was a natural choice for one using a slow and manoeuvrable aircraft as an I-16 or a biplane, and wasn't a guarantee against a diving Messerschmitt. To fly a MiG-3 as it was an I-16, turning on horizontal plan, was wrong against Bf-109E, that was able to turn with a 25% lower turning radius due to its lower wing load.
At higher altitudes, between 5,000 and 7,000 m, the MiG-3 was superior both on speed and manoeuvrability to the Bf-109E, and was comparable to the Bf-109F, but combat at such altitudes were rare on the Soviet-German front.

Many defects were noted during operative use, alongside the already known weak armament, tendency to spin, longitudinal instability and high landing speed:

Some defects, as spin tendency and bad horizontal manoeuvrability, were resolved on later produced aircrafts by installing slats, some other remained without a remedy.
  Some high-altitude combats were subcessful, demonstating that many defects shown on early aircrafts were resolved.
On September 28, 1941, the pilot B Pirozkhov of 124th IAP intercepted an enemy reconaissance plane at 8,000 m altitude, and followed it till to 10,000 m altitude shooting it down.
  The next thing was the developing of the so called “formula of victory”: altitude-speed-maneuver-fire. That means a fighter pilot should gain altitude, then transform it into speed, that speed into maneuver to get a good firing position.

That sound just too easy, but the main task of the VVS was to support the ground troops and that means for the fighters to protect the ground troops of enemy’s air attacks.   The normal way was to fly a combat circle over the area to protect.  This was good in a psychological way for the ground troops. Looking above the troops seeing there own fighters all the time:   ”Da, Da, there are our fighters, protecting us.”  But it was not good at all, because the German method was to send the Messerschmitts first to clean the airspace for the following bombers and that means they were coming from above shooting down circling Russian fighters. 

Pokryshkin used his basical physics knowledge about transforming potential energy into kinetic energy and vice versa. So they stopped flying circles over the area to protect and flew instead like a big pendulum over the area, having either altitude or speed all the time. This was not good in a psychological way for the ground troops seeing their fighters only when they reached the lowest point ( “Hey! Where are our fighters?") but of course much better in any other respect. Pokryshkin’s unit used that combat tactic first during the fights over Krymskaja and they did it with great success. This formula of victory was published in the Soviet army newspaper “Krasnaja Zvezda” (Red Star), so that the new combat experiences could be distributed all over the front.
 
back to MiG-3 main